The use of dispersants in marine oil spill response. May 29, 2012 in any particular situation, the decision to use dispersants involves balancing the potential advantages of dispersant useremoving oil from the water surface and avoiding some shoreline impactswith the potential disadvantages, such as impacts to plankton or other water column organisms. Chemical dispersants can suppress the activity of natural. This is captured in the following statement by the national research council nrc report on oil spill dispersants.
This document is the 1989 national research councils using oil spill dispersants on the sea. If an oil spill occurs in san juan county marine waters, responders may use. Comparative efficacy of two corexit dispersants as measured using. The window of opportunity for using dispersants is. Dispersant basics mechanism, chemistry, and physics of. Photochemical oxidation of oil reduced the effectiveness of aerial dispersants applied in response to the deepwater horizon spill, environmental science. Nevertheless, the application of this dispersant, both in the deepwater horizon incident and for other oil spills, remains controversial. The use of dispersants in marine oil spill response 2019 spills of diluted bitumen from pipelines 2016 a comparative study of environmental fate, effects, and response 2016 the bureau of safety and environmental enforcement bsee funds and conducts research on chemical agents.
Agencies in this jip are mms, noaa, api, and us coast guard. For example, bsee funded 28 projects on the efficacy of dispersants on different types of oil and under different ocean conditions. After the oil spill, two chemical dispersants, corexit ec9500a or corexit ec9527a, were used in some areas where oil was present. At the same time, using dispersants increases the exposure of water column and sea floor life to spilled oil. Approximately 3 million gallons of oil or refined petroleum products are spilled into u. Although significant steps have been taken over the last 15 years to reduce the size and frequency of oil spills, the sheer volume of petroleum consumed in the united states and the complex production and distribution network required to meet the. The addition of dispersants, however, has the potential to compound the toxicological effects on marine organisms by increasing the surface area of oil water interaction 29. Effectiveness remains a major issue with oil spill dispersants. The mixing action of the waves can cause oil and water to combine in two ways.
Graham, christine hale, emily maungdouglass, stephen sempier, ladon swann, and monica wilson. The results offered no compelling ecological reasons to prohibit use of dispersants in the nearshore environment sergy, 1985. Spilled oil floats on the sea surface in calm conditions. The deepwater horizon oil drilling rig on fire at the time of the spill. The use of chemical dispersants for oil spills chemistry. Given that the use of dispersants does not remove oil from the environment, dispersant use is only considered when the answer to this question is no, which then leads decision makers to evaluate the appropriateness of dispersant use. To monitor the efficacy of dispersant application, smart recommends three options, or tiers. In the spring of 2019, the national academies of sciences, engineering, and medicine also released a new report on the efficacy of using dispersants in response to marine oil spills and its effects on human health and the environment. Deepwater horizon oil spill and the use of dispersants in combating this spill. The synthetic dispersants, corexit ec 9500a and corexit ec 9527a, are effective in dispersing oil spills. Dispersants have been researched extensively and used for oil spill mitigation for more than 40 years, yet there are opportunities to enhance our understanding, including with respect to their long term fate and effects and how to optimize dispersant use. No fresh or brackish water effectiveness testing in this report.
Numerous laboratory test systems have been developed for the comparison of efficacy between various chemical oil dispersant formulations. Download a pdf of oil spill dispersants by the national research council for free. Aerial application of chemical dispersants to floating oil during and after spills is one tool used to minimize such risks. Jul, 2010 one of the most difficult decisions that oil spill responders and natural resource managers face during a spill is evaluating the tradeoffs associated with dispersant use, said the academy report, titled oil spill dispersants, efficacy and effects. Studies by gagnon and holdway 1999 showed that oil must be present at 500 parts per million for 3 h to be lethal to atlantic salmon. Gulf spill oil dispersants associated with health symptoms. The body of work done to date has provided important, but still limited understanding of many aspects of the efficacy of dispersants in the field and the behavior and toxicity of dispersed oil.
Bioactivity of oil dispersant used in the deepwater horizon cleanup operation. Dispersants do not remove oil from the water, but instead breakthe oil. Cdc oil spill response resources chemical dispersant. Jun 15, 2010 msds corexit 9527a pdf according to the deepwater horizon response unified commands website, as of june 14, 2010, over 1,262,000 gallons of dispersants have been used as part of bps oil spill cleanup efforts. Efficacy and effects, national research council 2005. Efficacy and effects oil spill prevention and response and deepwater horizon national research council, division on earth and life studies, ocean studies board, committee on understanding oil spill dispersants. Over a million litres of dispersant chemicals have been sprayed on the oil slick, mostly from planes. By enhancing the amount of oil that physically mixes into the water, dispersants can reduce the potential that a surface slick will contaminate shoreline habitats. In the uk toxicity test used to approve dispersants, between 100 and parts per million of dispersant are used in order to ensure that toxic effects can even be observed during the test, which lasts 100 min. Dispersant use involves a tradeoff between exposing coastal life to surface oil and exposing aquatic life to dispersed oil. Agencies used this information to modify how they were applying the dispersant. In the 198085 bios baffin island oil spill project, investigators sought to determine whether or not it was prudent to use dispersants on an oil slick approaching an arctic coastline. Toxicity of deepwater horizon source oil and the chemical.
Surprisingly little is known about the impacts of dispersants on the activity and abundance of hydrocarbondegrading microorganisms 25. The decision whether or not to use dispersants poses challenges. The project is a jip with many agencies involved in updating this document. Small droplets are easier to disperse throughout a water volume, and small droplets may be more readily biodegraded by microbes in the water. Ocean studies board annotation approximately 3 million gallons of oil or refined petroleum products are spilled into u. A trained observer, flying over the oil slick and using photographic job aids or advanced remote sensing instruments, assesses dispersant efficacy and reports back to the unified command. An effective oil spill response reduces risks to humans and ecosystems. Over 40 percent of the research projects were focused at least in part on testing dispersant effectiveness. Dispersants are being used in the deepwater horizon gulf of mexico response to remove oil from the surface of water where it can be especially harmful to the environment. The role of dispersants in mitigating oil spills is to break down the oil slick into stable droplets in the water column, thereby enhancing its rate of dissolution. They are chemicals that are applied directly to the spilled oil in order to remove it from the water surface, where oil can be especially harmful. As the national research council points out, adding a dispersant to an oil spill increases the hydrocarbon load on the ecosystem.
An oil dispersant is a mixture of emulsifiers and solvents that helps break oil into small droplets following an oil spill. The potential effects of dispersed oil on benthic flora and fauna e. Efficacy and effects description approximately 3 million gallons of oil or refined petroleum products are spilled into u. National research council of the national academies 2005 understanding oil spill dispersants. Oil from the 2010 spill flowed toward the coast of alabama, where it eventually washed ashore. Typically, the effects of oil spills have been very apparent on shorelines and coastal megafauna e. Efficacy and effects, board os, division on earth and life studies, national research council. Tier ii provides realtime data from the treated slick. Although significant steps have been taken over the last 15 years to reduce the size and frequency of oil spills, the sheer volume of petroleum consumed in the. Sunlight changes how well oil dispersants work on spills like the 2010 deepwater horizon disaster. Photochemical oxidation of oil reduced the effectiveness of.
What are some environmental impacts from dispersant use. Review and evaluate existing information regarding the efficacy and effects of dispersants as an oil spill response technique. By enhancing the amount of oil that physically mixes into the water, dispersants can reduce the potential. The need for green and nontoxic dispersants for oil spill remediation is growing. Specifically, nsf funded three projects looking at the use and effects of subsurface dispersant application, and bsee. Reducing occupational exposures while working with dispersants during the deepwater horizon response. The largescale applications of dispersants used at the surface and wellhead during the deepwater horizon oil spill raised many questions and highlighted the importance of understanding their effects on the marine environment. Rrts have established preapproval zones in most offshore areas dispersants used 8x in u. Monica wilson, larissa graham, chris hale, emily maungdouglass, stephen sempier, and ladon swann. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading oil spill dispersants.
When a dispersant is applied to an oil slick, its effectiveness in dispersing the spilled oil depends on factors such as oil properties, wavemixing energy, temperature, and salinity of the water. Dispersants have been researched extensively and used for oil spill mitigation for. Despite this, spill experts estimate that 30%50% of oil spills are either directly or indirectly caused by human error, with 20%40% of all spills caused by equipment failure or malfunction. There is insufficient understanding of the fate of dispersed oil in aquatic ecosystems. In principle, chemical dispersants are designed to reduce the oilwater interfacial tension allowing oil to form small oil droplets that disper. The deepwater horizon dwh oil spill was the first spill that occurred in the deep ocean, nearly one mile below the oceans surface. Efficacy and effects kindle edition by national research council, committee on understanding oil spill dispersants download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Is using dispersants on the bp gulf oil spill fighting. Chemical dispersants and their role in oil spill response. Sampling teams collected water samples to measure the amount of dispersed oil in the water column. You can learn more about the dispersants, and their effects, on the epas website, including information about. Sunlight reduces effectiveness of dispersants used in oil spills. The efficacy of dispersants in stimulating oil biodegradation is debated and negative environmental effects have been documented.
Oil spill dispersants also includes recommended steps for policy makers faced with making hard choices regarding the use of dispersants as part of spill contingency planning efforts or during actual spills. Aug 11, 2017 committee on understanding oil spill dispersants. Dispersant effectiveness on oil spills impact of salinity. Efficacy and effects of dispersants in oil spill response. Dispersant efficacy and effectiveness coastal response research. It is important to recognize that many factors influence dispersant effectiveness, including oil composition, sea energy, state of oil weathering, the type of dispersant used and the amount applied, temperature, and salinity of the water. The significance of oil spill dispersants sciencedirect. Sandler said since it was the first time oil dispersants had been used on such a large scale, it was important to examine the possible health effects.
Dispersants and their role in oil spill response 4 it is common knowledge that oil and water do not mix easily. The report concludes that more information on the potential bene. By enhancing the amount of oil that physically mixes into the water, dispersants can reduce the potential that a surface slick will contaminate shoreline. Throughout the summer of 2010 dispersants were used in unprecedented quantities and, in the case of subsea application. United kingdom, both the efficacy test morris and martinelli, 1983 and the toxicity. Chemical dispersants enhance the activity of oil and gas. The overall objective of this research was therefore to create a set of empirical data on three oils and two dispersants, by studying the variation in the effectiveness of the dispersants caused by changes in the salinity of seawater, temperature, oil type, oil weathering, dispersant type, and rotation speed. Potential immunotoxicological health effects following exposure to corexit 9500a during cleanup of the deepwater horizon oil spill. Baffled flask test bft at 41 and 77 of with slc oil 3 of 8 satisfactory dispersion results 70% efficacy similar results at cold and warm temperatures slc corexit 9500a 7580% lab dispersion. Volume 5 dispersants and their role in oil spill response. Sunlight reduces effectiveness of dispersants used to clean. Nearly two million gallons of dispersants were used at the waters surface and a mile below the surface to combat oil during the. Msds information for oil spill dispersants corexit 9500 and.
Waves will break up the oil slick and form oil droplets. However, for the assessment of chemical dispersant. Dispersant basics mechanism, chemistry, and physics of dispersants in oil spill response dispersant basics mechanism, chemistry, and physics of dispersants in oil spill response presentation to nrc committee on. Pdf oil dispersant effectiveness and ecological consequences in. For example, the 2005 national academy of sciences report, understanding oil spill dispersants. Efficacy and effects, suggested a number of areas where increased understanding would help support the use of dispersants. Efficacy and effects book from the description listed on the nap site. In contrast, relatively few projects were focused on applying dispersants subsurface or in the arctic. Visit bsees master list of publications on oil spill research. Cdc oil spill response resources reducing occupational. Modified swirling flask efficacy test for oil spill dispersants, spill science and technology bulletin, 4, pp. Efficacy and effects national academies press stating that todays dispersants are much less toxic than those used several decades ago.
Preparation of dispersant and oil water accommodated. Dispersants are being used in the deepwater horizon gulf of mexico response to remove oil from the surface of water where it. In the past, some dispersants were linked to disorders in humans and animals, but in 2005, the national research center nrc released a report, understanding oil spill dispersants. Efficacy and effects, suggested a number of areas where increased. Approximately 3 million gallons of oil or refined petroleum products are spilled. National academies press, 2005 dlc 2005931459 ocolc631910. Efficacy and effects the ocean studies board, part of the national academies division on earth and life studies dels, has released a report that examines the adequacy of existing information and ongoing research regarding the effectiveness of dispersants as an oil spill response technique, as well as the effect of.
Efficacy and effects committee on understanding oil spill dispersants staff national research council u s. Oil dispersants chemical agents such as surfactants, solvents, and other. The use of chemical dispersants to combat oil spills at sea. Oil dispersants chemical agents such as surfactants, solvents, and other compounds are used to reduce the effect of oil spills by changing the chemical and. Once oil has spilled, people use oil spill countermeasures to try to reduce the adverse effects of spilled oil on the environment. Emsa held a workshop on the use of oil spill dispersants in european waters in brussels in. Jun 18, 2010 roughly five million liters of dispersants have now been used to break up the oil spilling into the gulf of mexico, making this the largest use of such chemicals in u.
899 302 1531 129 573 764 273 508 384 652 855 1101 1340 1060 630 522 793 607 960 1516 1151 1684 620 1239 1189 1363 165 967 538 736 80 519 291 1490 1050